Outdoor Federation

Bog Boots vs Muck Boots

Outdoor Federation is supported by its readers. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Also, as an Amazon affiliate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Winter is fast approaching, which means it’s time to get out your old winter boots… and then promptly remember that by March last year, they were letting in water and leaving your feet like icicles after the shortest walk to the shops.

Bog Boots vs Muck Boots

Choosing a new pair of winter waterproof boots, whether you’re after something for day-to-day use or need something for outdoor work or leisure during the colder weather, is rarely a simple decision. How much should you be paying for a decent pair? Which brands are the most reputable? And most importantly, how can you ensure you get the most bang for your buck?

Two best-selling boot options on Amazon might catch your eye in particular: the Muck Boot Arctic Sport Rubber High Performance Men’s Winter Boot , and the Bogs Womens Classic High Handle Waterproof Insulated Rain and Winter Snow Boot. It’s easy to see why these boots are so popular at the moment, with both boasting a range of proven benefits and an impressive array of positive reviews.

If you’re considering purchasing either one of these pairs of boots, but can’t decide which one is the suitable choice for you, you’ll find all the information you’ll need to compare the two of them below:

Last update on 2023-07-18 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

First impressions

Muck boot : The Muck Boot Arctic Sport Rubber High Performance Men’s Winter Boot is a waterproof, shock absorbing, heat retaining boot made from synthetic rubber with a rubber sole. It’s black in colour, and is offered in a size range of US 9 to 16 M women or 15 M men. It is fitted with a soft inner fleece lining and thermal foam underneath the footbed, and has an outsole with molded lugs to make it easier to get about on uneven terrain.

Bogs boot : The Bogs Womens Classic High Handle Waterproof Insulated Rain and Winter Snow Boot is a 100% rubber tall rain boot that’s suitable for rainy and wintery weather conditions. It can be purchased in “black” or “black smooth” shades, and is offered in a size range of 6 to 12 women. It features pull-on handles and an anti-microbial odor protection insole with a non-slip rubber outsole for safe walking.


Muck boot: The Muck Boot Arctic Sport Rubber High Performance Men’s Winter Boot promises to keep feet warm in temperatures dropping down to minus 40 degrees. The boots’ waterproof capabilities make them suitable for walking in deep rain, snow or slush.

Bog boot: The Bogs Womens Classic High Handle Waterproof Insulated Rain and Winter Snow Boot features high handles with an upper rubber shaft and removable insole. With a non-slip rubber outsole, the boots are an appropriate cold weather footwear solution.

Fun Outdoor Quiz

About the company

Muck boot: The Original Muck Boot Company has been manufacturing its collection for over two decades, and has grown its line to include over 60 different styles of footwear. The brand focuses on comfort and quality, and offers its products to customers worldwide.

Bog boot: Bogs originated from Oregon, which is known for its damp and cold climate. It fast became the brand’s mission to provide comfort despite the weather conditions, and its functional footwear has been tested for versatility, warmth, waterproofing abilities, and ease of use.

Last update on 2023-07-18 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API


Muck boot: Reviews of the muck boot are generally positive. Good reviews cite the manufacturer as being a “number one seller for a reason”, and praise the boots for being “durable, rugged and extremely warm”. They’re cited as being effective in cold weather and snowy conditions, and “less bulky” than a buyer might imagine.

The reviews that give a poor rating for the muck boot mentioned tears in the material after little use, and an inability to keep feet warm. Other reviewers complained that the boots leaked in damp conditions.

Bog boot: The bog boot has received similar positive reviews. Many owners praised them for being “warm and waterproof”, “easy to slip on and off”, and “appropriate for wet and muddy weather”. Others mentioned the boots’ durability and comfortable inner lining.

The poor rating reviews focused on the “poor quality and fit” of the boots. Some owners mentioned that the boots were “falling apart” and left them with “wet toes”, while others complained about the “lack of traction” in the outer rubber sole.

Overall impression

If you’re looking for a pair of heavy-duty winter boots that will keep your feet warm in spite of the elements, it’s pretty clear that either the Muck Boot Arctic Sport Rubber High Performance Men’s Winter Boot or the Bogs Womens Classic High Handle Waterproof Insulated Rain and Winter Snow Boot will be appropriate for you. Both boots offer very similar insulating and waterproofing benefits and negative reviews for both are few and far between.

Ultimately, your final decision on which, if any, boot to purchase, may have to come down to which shoe you like the appearence of the most. You might also want to consider which boot will be the best fit for your foot. Keep the size measurements for each in mind. If you’re considering going through with a purchase, it’s also a good idea to check the FAQs and reviews for the product to check whether other buyers are finding that the boots fit their feet in their usual size, or whether they have to go up or down a size for the best fit.

Do Bogs Boots Run Big or Small?

Bogs Footwear Boots are manufactured in European foot sizes. The design for foot sizes is intended for the comfort of your feet. The sizes are wider through the forefoot, supporting the arches, and then narrows into the heels. The design combinations of the shoe sizes fit in with a much wider range of widths and lengths.

This eliminates the need for half-foot sizes and widths. For people with half size, the recommended size to choose is the next full size. This will give some allowance in the boot size, and also allow the right circulation of airflow. Bogs Footwear has different foot sizes, depending on the availability in local retailers.

The industry accepts different measurements so there are no exact conversions throughout different international foot sizes. For an accurate foot size for Bogs Footwear, it is recommended to use a Brannock measuring device by a trained professional.

Are Bogs Boots Good for Winter?

 Winter is tough because of the snow and for that, you need a high-quality pair of boots. Bogs Footwear boots can withstand negative 400 F in the event of heavy hails, ice pellets, and rainfall, and snow mixed. It has a technology called Neo-tech, a four-way stretch fabric for flexibility and for temperature ratings. It has a lighter version that comes with 2 mm of the Neo-Tech and Airmesh.

Bogs Footwear also offers 7 mm of Neo-Tech that can sustain negative 400. The footwear is a sturdy, waterproof, and insulated pair of boots perfect for the winter. It is also a good investment for the rainy seasons so it will be like hitting two birds in one stone. It also keeps your feet warm, whether you are walking, running, climbing, or playing in the snow. It comes in different beautiful designs and colors – in toddler, kid, and adult sizes.

Are Bogs Boots Waterproof?

Bogs Footwear boots are made with high-quality materials, and are one hundred percent waterproof. The boots that are manufactured and designed with the technology called Neo-tech is perfect to keep safe and warm from chilly waters. Although it is perfect for any condition, these sturdy and high-quality boots are not made for fire walking. These boots are well insulated that will keep your feet toasty in rainy seasons. It also comes with slip-resistant and antimicrobial features.

For women’s boots, there are different boot materials to choose from such as leather, rubber, and fabric. They also come in different designs perfect for OOTDs. For men, if looking for sturdy and working boots, Bogs Footwear offers boots and loafers, and work boots in different foot sizes up to size 17. For kids, the Bogs Footwear boots are designed with handles so that they will easily pull off and on. This way, kids can easily wear them.

Do Muck Boots Stretch?

Muck boots are stretchable. These boots are manufactured to standard widths and so, the boots can be stretched to fit widths up to ultra-wide fitting. Everyone has different feet dimensions and it is important to invest in a correct fitting boot. For people that have narrower feet, it is recommended to wear a thick sock or invest in a sock liner to fill up the room.

The product is made out of rubber and can be stretched in usual ways. The product is manufactured and designed with elastic rubber so they stretch, and have a grip close against the calves so that you can step on the deepest part of a puddle or snow that will prevent your foot from getting wet.  Muck Boots are offered in whole sizes only but they can be stretched in half sizes. For example, a Muck boots size 9 can be stretched up to 9 and half size.

Are Muck Boots Slip-Resistant?

Muck boots are slip-resistant. The manufacturer has a reputation for producing high-quality products that meet the expectation of consumers around the globe. Muck Boots has offered sixty designs over the last two decades in the industry.

The boots are made out of leather and rubber – all designed to withstand harsh conditions, be it the mountain, farm, or city. One of the best non-slip footwear of Muck is the Muck Boots Chore Oil, Chemical & Slip Resistant Steel Toe Men’s Rubber Work Boot available in Amazon. It has a rubber sole and shaft that measures approximately 14 inches from the arch.

The sole has a V-wave design with a slip resistance compound, thus improving grip on the slippery ground including steel and ceramic tile. It also has the RDR compound that is resistant to oil-based fluids and other chemicals. These boots are perfect for the harsh working environment such as factories, construction sites, industrial sites, and other slippery working environments.

Are Muck Boots Good for Hiking?

Yes, Muck boots are good for hiking. For people who love going out in the woods, camping, fishing and hunting, hiking, and working in tough environments, this pair of boots works. The boots’ shaft is approximately 7 inches from the arch and heels, and measures approximately 1.75 inches. The product is one hundred percent made of leather and it is designed to withstand the tough environment in mountains.

Whether you are walking on harsh terrain, hiking, or backpacking, this pair of boots works well. One of the boots worth your money for hiking is the Muck Boots Woodland Extreme Hunting Boot. The product is lightweight and insulated with 6mm of Neoprene. This will keep your feet toasty, comfortable, and waterproof. It is designed with an ethylene vinyl acetate midsole that supports your steps while hiking. The outsole of the boots is rugged and durable for maximum guard and stability.

Amazon Best Sellers of Muck Boots and Bogs Boots

SaleBestseller No. 1
BOGS Mens Ultra Mid Waterproof Boot Black Size 10
BOGS Mens Ultra Mid Waterproof Boot Black Size 10
100% Waterproof; Durable hand-lasted rubber and a four way stretch inner bootie; Non-slip and non-marking outsole
SaleBestseller No. 2
BOGS Mens Classic High Boot Black Size 12
BOGS Mens Classic High Boot Black Size 12
Neoprene and rubber; Rubber sole; 100% waterproof; 7mm neoprene liner; Comfort rating to -40 degrees
Bestseller No. 3
Muck Women's Originals Ankle Boots,...
Muck Women's Originals Ankle Boots,...
100% waterproof; Full neoprene bootie exposed at sides for added comfort and easy on/off; 6" Upper
SaleBestseller No. 4
Muck Boots Hale Multi-Season Kids' Rubber...
Muck Boots Hale Multi-Season Kids' Rubber...
Pull-on boot with textured outsole featuring mesh sock liner and Muck branding at shaft; Rear pull tab and wide opening allows for easy on-off
SaleBestseller No. 5
Muck Boot Women's Muckster II Mid Rain Boot,...
Muck Boot Women's Muckster II Mid Rain Boot,...
A True Performance Product; Quality Assured; Designed With The User In Mind; Tested For Function In A Real-World Environment
SaleBestseller No. 6
BOGS unisex child York Waterproof Rainboot Rain...
BOGS unisex child York Waterproof Rainboot Rain...
100% Waterproof Kids Insulated Rain Boots; Comfort Rated to -4 Degrees F/-20 Degrees C; Constructed with 5mm Neo-Tech waterproof insulation

Last update on 2023-07-18 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

And with that, we officially end this blog post. But before you go, can you do us a solid and spread the love (or laughter) by sharing this on your social media? Who knows, maybe we might even find someone who can relate to our content and benefit from it... Wink